Preston Toyota of New Castle

This review is to specifically recognize the outstanding outgoing above-and-beyond efforts for salesman Anthony Yeager. We had been in the market for a new Camry (2026) as an out of state couple (from Ashland Ohio). He was so helpful with disclosing important vehicle information, pictures, packages etc on the car we were inquiring about. No stone left unturned. He was super punctual, and communicated well, even in his days off!! (Thank you for that). We ended up having to pass on the car for the time being due to issues that arose with our local Toyota dealer (in legal dispute now) so we were unable to purchase a vehicle from Preston Toyota as of yet. But he deserves all the credit where it’s due. Being very helpful, meticulous, and accommodating. If you’re in the market for a new or used

I cannot say enough incredible things about Walt Kustra at Preston Toyota of New Castle, PA. Walt is the sole reason I have purchased every one of my vehicles from him for well over 12 years, and I wouldn’t even consider going anywhere else. His professionalism, integrity, knowledge, and genuine care for his customers are simply unmatched. Walt doesn’t just sell vehicles — he builds long-term relationships and trust, and that’s exactly why I keep coming back time and time again. He consistently goes above and beyond, makes the process smooth and stress-free, and always ensures you’re taken care of before, during, and long after the sale. He is truly an exceptional manager and an even better person. I also want to give a huge shout-out to Anthony Yeager, the salesman who sold me my truck.

We worked with Gary Stone and cannot say enough good things about him and the entire process of buying our dream car/long term investment. We feel we left with a great deal on a car that dealers cannot keep in stock (NEW Grand Highlander Hybrid). Zero pressure the entire time. At the end of the day they offered us a great deal right up front on both vehicle and extended warranties (Alex Pherson - Finance) without any games or gimmicks. They gave us their best and even helped sweeten the deal with an add-on we wanted at an amazing price! I cannot speak highly enough about both Gary Stone and Alex. I can say that when we move 5 hrs away in a couple years, we will do the drive to purchase from this dealership, with hopes Gary and Alex are still here. But I do trust the way they do business af

Preston Toyota made my car buying experience nice and easy. I worked with Salesman Gary Stone. Gary did a solid job. I started with an internet inquiry then a couple of phone calls with Gary and I purchased a new Tundra without stepping on the lot. Everything was arranged on line and over the phone. When I finally made it to Preston Toyota Gary had everything in order to make my Tundra buying experience very easy. Also, a very nice job done by Alex in Finance. Thanks guys!

An absolute awesome purchasing experience! Big shoutout to the salesman Anthony. He was extremely kind, upfront, and thorough about everything. Any questions I had were answered even via message immediately. Also can’t beat their pricing compared to other dealerships within 100 miles.