Payton Place Auto

We had a great experience at Payton Place Auto in Columbus, IN. Conner made the whole car-buying process completely painless, nothing like the stressful experiences we’ve had at other dealerships. He was professional, honest, and easy to work with. They even went above and beyond by replacing the battery without us even asking. If you’re looking for a trustworthy used car dealership in Columbus, Indiana, I highly recommend Payton Place Auto.

Robby at Payton Auto in Seymour IN is the best. We bought a Cherokee in April and then I decided to see if it would swim. Stupid me it doesn't. Thank God we bought GAP insurance. My husband was able to go today and get another vehicle. Robby worked so hard again for us. Payton Auto you have a winner in Robby and that's an understatement. What he has done for us is way over and above.

People are scammers, says they go by “market value” then I find the same exact car for 12,000$ less. And multiple other great deals on similar cars for WAY less money, Literally go anywhere but here. You’ll find a better deal, I promise you that. Then after having a short conversation with the person on Facebook, and I tell them I’m gonna write a bad review they block me to keep me from doing so! And I’m sure they’ll try and get this deleted as well.

Wasn't looking for another vehicle but these guys phenomenal and I walked away happy as a camper and they stand behind you every step of the whole process and beyond . One of the best car buying experience I've ever had , I absolutely 💯 ! Recommend them Connor, Tanner and staff truly care about their customers and it shows.. Mad love and much respect for them. Awesome group of guys. In the market for a vehicle stop in a see them tell them Kimberly sent you!!

Just bought my awesome jeep from Tanner, and the process was AMAZING!! 10/10 recommend!!! Although the process was amazing, I’ve come back to let everyone know that this vehicle is a hunk of junk. Not even six months later and it breaks down every week. Go buy a NEW vehicle with great warranties from a different dealership. I’ve reached out to Tanner and was expected to get a phone call back, but never has returned said phone call. I’m pretty mad for the price I paid, I’m having to pay the service department more than my actual payment for the damn jeep.