Stillwater Auto Sales

Mike made buying a car a stress-free and honest experience. He’s incredibly kind and upfront, answering all my questions without any pressure. The quality of his cars is impressive — you can tell he takes great care in what he sells. If you want a trustworthy, no-nonsense dealer who truly cares, definitely buy from Mike. I’m really happy with my car and the whole process.

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! Mike is absolutely phenomenal! I recently took my dad to buy him a 2016 Mazda CX-5, and the entire experience was beyond anything we could have hoped for. From the very first moment, Mike went above and beyond — he took the time to walk us through every detail of the car, answered all our questions honestly, and never once made us feel pressured. His kindness, patience, and upfront approach made us feel completely comfortable and confident in our decision. What really blew us away was his integrity after the sale. Mike mentioned that if the brakes didn’t improve within 500 miles, he would personally cover the repair. Sure enough, they didn’t — and not only did he follow through on his word, but the repair ended up costing more than expected, and he still covered it co

I had no expectations when I went to Stillwater Auto Sales, which was to my credit. I knew what I wanted and that was it, though expecting car buying to be an unpleasant chore. I left in exactly the car I wanted, happier and more confident in that transaction than I've ever felt. That's to the owner Mike's credit. How do you make someone feel like you're putting their best interests first? Actually put their best interests first. Thank you so much! Rewarding experience, I highly recommend it. Hopefully I won't need to visit there for a while, but I won't hesitate to go back, or recommend him to any honest car buyer.

The most amazing experience! Mike is one of the kindest, most genuine people I’ve ever met in the car business. There was zero pressure, just honest guidance and true professionalism from start to finish. If you want to work with someone who truly cares about his customers, go see Mike!!

I bought a Subaru from Mike. The whole process was pleasant and easy. My new car has hail damage, which for me is such a no brainer trade off for cost vs the age and low mileage of the vehicle. Mike was recommended by a friend who also bought a car from him, and I was not disappointed!